Newsletter platform reviews, tested first-hand
We open a real account, use the product, read every review we can find in full, and score each platform out of 10 with the reasoning published. Commission never enters the math. How we test and score.
Kit8.1 / 10The highest score our engine has produced, from a platform that pays us nothing: panel-leading automation and free-plan commerce. The catch: an AUP that bans affiliate-type sites and billing that never downgrades itself.
Read the full review →
beehiiv7.4 / 10The most complete monetization toolkit for creators, with a free plan that caps at 2,500 subscribers and a real account-suspension pattern to know about.
Read the full review →
MailerLite7.3 / 10The easiest and best-supported tool we tested, with a 0%-commission stack and EU data residency. The catch: an algorithm that can suspend an account with no human appeal.
Read the full review →
Buttondown6.7 / 10The developer-grade minimalist: the best founder-direct support in our panel, a 0% fee on every revenue stream and a real CLI. The catch: deliberately thin analytics and a single-founder product.
Read the full review →
AWeber6.3 / 10The only ESP in our panel where a human answers the phone, plus a free tier its own pricing page never mentions. But the plan counts your unsubscribes and the terms allow no-notice suspension.
Read the full review →
Substack5.4 / 10Free to start and genuinely strong at discovery, but it takes 10% of your paid revenue, support is a chatbot, and the trust record is the hardest in our panel.
Read the full review →
More reviews are in the works. In the meantime, the recommendation quiz and the head-to-head comparisons cover every platform we track.